WHO RAN IT?!

1st ! omg im 1st ! yeeeeaaaaahhhhhh !

I’m mad they have the same hair and everything…..it’s a tie because they look the same!

First!! I think Cici

I hate both. They look like cloes… let me not go into some commentary on the music industry’s mass production of “talent” and just say I like Ciara’s because of the hair.

My girl B gave it to’em!

by cloes I ment clones

Ciara. By faaaaar. Beyonce bootyliciousness *gag*….is just too much for that dress to handle and still look good on her.

I think Ciara wore it better because she is taller and it makes the back look better. Beyonce needs to sit down and take a break before she does a Mariah and Matthew is not going to like that cause he will be losing money. LOL!!!

BEYONCE FILLED IT OUT MUCH BETTER.

I have to say CiCi did, but they both look fab. I do like CiCi’s hair more so.

A for afford
F on originality.

BEYONCE FILLED IT OUT MUCH BETTER. CIARA TO ME LOOKS LIKE A LITTLE GIRL PLAYING DRESS UP.

ciara

I love Beyonce, but I would have to go with Ciara. Only because I don’t like Beyonce’s hair.

BEYONCE!!!!!!!!!!!!

Beyonce ran it better. Cici looks like a man in a dress

What do you mean Mart-ay that is too much for that dress to handle?? Beyonce looks super FAB, sexy and tasteful. Cici I love you but honestly you look like a 12 year old boy in that dress drink some milk and get your weight up.

I would have to say neither one because that dress was not made for them at all!!!! But at a glance CiCi looks like Tyra in the pic

Beyonce by far! The dress is for a mature body, and Beyonce filled it out perfectly!

I call it a tie. They both looked nice in it however, Beyonce filled it out better and I like that Ciara wore straight hair with it. It gaver her a sleeker look.

I was going to see Ciara, but now as I’m looking at it again I say they both do not look their best.

A for afford
F on originality.
To what– “EFFORT” is spelled with an E.

I think ciara rocked it better!!!

Beyonce rocked it 10 times better. It looks great on her.

Its a tie on this one…

It looks like the same person! Same hair color and all. Sigh, but I’ll give it to Beyonce’ for not rocking a Mama Tina design. I HAVE to encourage anything that Mama Tina did not make!

I think they both look nice but I’m going to say Beyonce since she rocked it first. Ciara almost as the same hair style (sigh) and the pose.

If I had to pick one Ciara -Only because I liked the straight hair better. To be honest they both looked hot. And I don’t know why people say Cirar looks like a boy because she doesn’t.

well they rocked it very similar … i’d give it a tie.

Ci Ci looked more sultry and effortless. Be’s hair I don’t really care for but they both looked nice.

BEYONCE’,BEYONCE’

Beyonce rocked the dress much better. One because she wore it first- shes an original trend setter. Two- Beyonce wore nice earrings with it to complete her look. Three- B’s hair looks hot… anyone with some weave could get Ciara’s hair style here..but it takes more effort to do those curls that B rocked. I dunno, to me Ciara was boring…boring hair, no accessories, and shes bold enough to wear the same outfit (different designer) that B had.

If Tyra Banks saw this, she would tell Ciara that if your going to rock and copy another girls look, you better do it 10x better- or dont do it at all. Thats what she told one girl in a past cycle when she tried to take the same poses as another girl, and didnt rock them like the orignal gal.

LOL, you just gotta say ciara looks like a man…even when she doesnt! I think it’s a habit??? She looks beautiful, and yet….we still say she looks like a man!!!

I say it’s between bootylicious Beyonce and crunkalicious Ciara.

Mz.Delilah wrote:

A for afford
F on originality.
To what– “EFFORT” is spelled with an E.

It’s a saying….even though it was spelled wrong

I say it’s a TIE between bootylicious Beyonce and crunkalicious Ciara.

I don’t know….a tie? Ciara from the front…B from the back?

Beyonce!!!
The designer of Ciara’s dress needs to be arrested or sued for that one. Its clearly a knock off. B had it on months ago.

Is that the only hairstyle appropriate for the dress? I think they both rocked it.

I agree with Kells CiCi did look like Tyra at first glance. I say CiCi ran it. It’s interesting how they all seem to go for the same look in the music industry. I dont know who came up with honey blond hair dye but damn these chicks seem to live off of it. Or try to go for a colour quite close.

They both look fly its all good people.

Beyonce of course…

BEYONCE! CIARA’S BACK IS TOO WIDE..

Hate the dress. Who cares about who wore it better?

Ciara looks the best. Does anyone personally know someone that buys “House of Do it Wrong?”

Beyonce!

Irene wrote:

Hate the dress. Who cares about who wore it better?

LoL

They both look off, their hair looks plastic.

I think Ciara rocked it her hair did the trick although B looks good I thinks she’s overrated.

Beyonce!

Beyonce all the way… Not to mention she rocked it first so she get’s it hands down… and the material of Ciara’s dress looks cheap.

i like ciaras hair better but beyonce got more curves.

B rocked Roberto Cavalli and Ciara rocked Gucci, Gucci is never a knock off.

Well, CLEARLY Ciara copied Beyonce. She did not only wear the dress, but she stole the hairstyle as well. Ciara was not creative with it at all.

They both look gorgeous, but Beyonce has a more feminine shape. So I’ll give her the edge. But if I were Ciara I wouldn’t hesitate to wear it.

Beyonce is wearing the dress and looks comfortable. Ciara ia aloowing the dress to wear her. It doesn’t fit her well.

Beyonce’s body looks better in the dress, but Ciara’s hair was sleeker and cuter. I give em a tie.

That said, the black Jessica Rabbit thing ain’t my fave look on either one of these hoes. NEXT!

They both ROCKED IT! Why couldn’t let go of the outrageous weave for just 1 night and pull their hair up? Both would have looked better with a buns, chignons or pony tails.

By far Beyonce ran it!!!!!!!!!!!and for all you b haters, chill and learn to love yourself, B is bad!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

beyonce for the taking… doesnt beyonce always win these?!?!?

I DONT CARE FOR EITHER ONE OF THEM AND IF U ASK ME , I THINK KEISHA COLE WOULD HAVE ROCKED IT BETTER………………………………..

Beyonce even though I’m tired of both of them

Ciara’s looks great and all, but I’d have to give it to B. I like curves on my lady, and B rocks the concept better.

I think Ci ran it because her hair gives the dress a sleeker look. They are both pretty tho.

Definitely CiCi!!! She looks so much more sleek and chic in it. Go CiCi!

B was swagger jacked once again! She rocked it best. I like the curly weave better than Ciara’s weave. Ciara’s stylist should be fired for being so unoriginal.

Beyonce. Her curves make the dress look good, and I like that she accessorised it a tad bit more than Ciara..

CIARA WINS HANDS DOWN. effortless, elegant, and classy personified

BEYONCE IS FAT. PLAIN AND SIMPLE.

AND CASSIE WORE THIS DRESS FIRST IF YOU WANNA GOO ON THAT. WITH THE SAME HAIR STYLE AND ALL. AIN’T NOONE COPYING BEYONCE.TTHERE IS NOTING ORIGINAL ABOUT BEYONCE

Ciara all the way!!!!

Yall know Beyonce killed it…CiCi’s back is not sexy

I love Beyonce and Ciara but I can’t choose cause they look the same. They have the same hair and everything. Their poses are even the same.

They look like the same person in the same dress.

natasha, when you ask who ran it better why don’t you have a poll so at least your readers know the answer counts, or just the overall winner?

Beyonce. CiCi isnt filling it out as well.

Beyonce rocked it—I mean couldn’t ciara change up the hairstyle atleast. Originality people–It’s necessary.

beyonce won, but that dress is so ugly to me

Ciara copied! B did it better!
p.s. ciara does look like tyra on that pic….

Beyonce won hands down! She’s always HOT!

Ok…honestly y’all already know I’m super-addicted to Beyonce and I’m not being biased…cause i will say when she looks a mess…but even before I scrolled down and saw “Who Ran It?” I busted out laughing at Ciara…my co-worker said she looks like an extra in a bad remake of Resident Evil and I simply must agree….the dress is horrible but Beyonce wore it the best because she always looks graceful….and yes i agree Ciara does look like a man as usual…*leaves singing loudly “It’s Raining Men Hallelujah It’s Raining Men!”…LMAO

To all ya’ll hataz…….QUEEEN B ROCKED IT OF COURSE SO QUIT YA HATIN HOS! OF COURSE I LIKE CIARA BUT SHE NEED MORE CURVES AND THE HAIR DIDN’T MATCH THE DRESS! BEYONCE ROCKED IT.

tlb wrote:

Beyonce rocked it—I mean couldn’t ciara change up the hairstyle atleast. Originality people–It’s necessary.

completely agreed!
Seeing as how Ciara went and got another designer to duplicate the look and lace front Im gonna go with B. Her lace front game is unbeatable. ciaras lacefront look like michael jacksons in the front!!

mochacinnamon wrote:

I say it’s a TIE between bootylicious Beyonce and crunkalicious Ciara.

True!! True!! My thoughts exact…

Some gowns aren’t made for black women,therefore the dress looks better on Ciarra.

Beyonce’ has too many curves

“Who Stole It?” is the question. That’s the same exact dress on both of them and somebody designed it first. And somebody jacked it for their own line later.

cici baby girl u tryin too hard. B has been putin it down for years now.yes years. haters stop hating Beyonce ran it

Whoever said Beyonce is fat needs to be shot or is either an angry Ciara stan b/c Beyonce CLEARLY won this by a million miles. She has the best body in the business. Them curves are to die for. Ciara did copy her. She even copied her pose. Ciara please sit down u will never be Bey’s level!

Beyonce rocked it better by far,Ciara looks uncomfortable and boyish,plus Bey wore it first…I think Ci stole the whole thing from Bey,I mean the same hair color…and hair swiped to the side…why couldn’t she have worn the dress when her hair was black…and even the same pose…so I think Ci tryna jack Bey’s style…but it ain’t working Ci

I’m not a fan of d dress. But if i were to choose, i’ll choose Miss B.

Ciara looks sexy, sultry, like a professional model.
Beyonce looks like she’s modeling in a store-front church fashion show.

Kelly wrote:

Ciara looks the best. Does anyone personally know someone that buys “House of Do it Wrong?”

LMAO!!!

i couldn’t tell them apart at first, and you really should get a poll or something… a tally, SOMETHING.
ima give it to Ci though, HONESTLY, there are some b haters that like her better but just going w/ ciara out of spite, and there’s some b stans that hated it on b, but chose her just because….same w/ the ciara ppl.
but in my honest opinion, beyonces smile threw me off, she look like a robot.

B ran it of course. C is too narrow for this dress. B has the curves to properly fill it out. Go B!

ciara’ gucci dress is not a knock off and looks fabulous

the cavalli dress beyonce has on does not look good on her, it looked better on Adrianna Lima abd Cassie

by the way beyonce did not wear it first, cassie did with the same hairstyle and everything

Ciara, no doubt - the body is WAY better and so is the hair and face. Bey looks like a man dressed as a woman - WAY too dragg-queeny!

Minus both “horrid” laceront wigs, Beyonce worked it much better.
An hourglass figure is a must for that dress and we all know that Ciara doesn’t qualiy for that catagory…

Ciara ran it. Her long and lean frame looks much better. No slight to Beyonce’, she just deos not look comfortable and the neck looks like it’s choking her. Ciara has a more toned physique so the back looks better as well. Ci Ci ran this flawlessly in my opinion.

-Beyonce wore it best!!

Does Ciara do anything original?

I’m gonna say Beyonce, since she did it first.

im not a hater, but they both look a mess. can we get some creativity and leave the wigs and weaves alone?

You and I both know Beyonce does her thing… CiCi (she’s cute, but she needs a few more years before she can get on Bee’s level).

lol Ciara looks like aman in that dres wit her lack of hips and flat booty…

I can’t believe i’m about to write this. Cici really looked better.But Beyonce still looks nice.

Beyonce hands down. The curves rule. Plus why did Ciara’s people let her rock the exact same look as her competition? Everyone knows that Beyonce is way more talented, beautiful, and a bigger star. Fire that stylist Ciara!

they both need to get rid of that stupid fake hair and take a page out of rhi rhi’s short looks and brandi’s or serena’s of late. Keep it believable and fresh damn! You have enough money!

Beyonce ran it!! ciara has a boy’s body, yuck

I would go with CiCi because as much as Beyonce tries to hide it she is going to unfold just like mom.. good luck JayZ.

ciara rocked it better imo. She has the frame of a model. And she looks sultry and seductive.

I think Both Ciara and Bey Rock the dress, they both look soooo amazing

they both look good, but me coming form a hispanic background where all your curve are beutifull… i think beyonce rocked it better then cici!

brightstarr wrote:

I don’t know….a tie? Ciara from the front…B from the back?

My thoughts exactly.

WHERE TF IS THE “NEITHER” BUTTON? YOU DOPES

They are both beautiful and talented girls and they both could’ve wore something a little less Morticia Adams-ish. I don’t like either dress.

Isn’t that a Cavalli dress? Are you sure Ciara’s isn’t by the same designer as Beyonce’s???

Who rocked it best? I’m gonna have to go with Beyonce. She fills it out better.

Beyonce definitely, but Ci-Ci’s hair is best.

BEYONCE GOT IT!!!! CIARA ALWAYS LOOKS LIKE A MAN LOL Y WOULD SHE EVEN THINK TO WEAR A FORM FITTED DRESS WHEN SHE HAS NO HIPS

This is clearly another case of Ciara trying to be Beyonce’s clone. Give it up boo boo youl’ll never be Beyonce so quit trying!!!

ciara

Cherri wrote:

Ciara looks sexy, sultry, like a professional model.
Beyonce looks like she’s modeling in a store-front church fashion show.

LMAO! yea its something off with both of these pics! But I do agree with whoever suggested a poll…so we could actually see the results of what everybody thought…

I think honestly that ciara rocked it better, cause beyonce hair looked to cheesy for me with that dress in everything.In ciara had her model status going on, she wore no earrinngs wich made the dress look sexy in sleek. in beyonce made it look hard in cheesy. Although i saw the gurls a their best in i beleive this wasnt their best.

always, a fan of both, n love them the same
danika

I vote from the neck down, Beyonce because she does fill it out better. & from the neck up Ciara because her hair & make up is better. Beyonce’s make up makes her look a lot older.

CiCi rocked it better in the front and Beyonce killed it in the back! For a dress taht ugly, you have to have some booty to fill it out in the back and CiCi, just doesn’t have that. CiCi’s hair does look better though.

@ Elve,

Do you really think she’s trying to be like Beyonce? Are you kidding me? Ciara is a far superior dancer and if anything, she’s emulating Janet Jackson more than Beyonce (who at times all emulate Janet dancewise)… That’s pretty weird, but your opinion right? Still…

ofcurse beyonce i saw b wearing it b4 ciara and damn ciara did the same hair style it looks better with beyonce!!!!

Beyonce deff luks bettah she filled it out bettah

Ciera. Definitely!!

OK first off the dress is U-G-L-Y but just to judge who made it look better was my girl B she rocked this so much better bcuz she has the shape for it and ciara has the shape of a bonie ass model with no a$$ nor tits so Beyonc3

B HANDS DOWN!

CIARA LOOKS LIKE A DRAG QUEEN IN THAT DRESS & HER HAIR IS A HOT